Honesty inherits the earth or does it?
Dear Evan Hansen Musical Director’s Word
I’m sure we’ve all had moments in our lives where we’ve had to leave something unsaid or we’ve had to resort to so-called “untold things”. white lie. But when is a lie white? When is lying allowed? Does the end justify the means?
The protagonist of our musical, Evan Hansen, finds himself in a situation where he does not dare to tell the truth. The fear of correcting the misunderstanding that has arisen drives him into a spiral of lies from which there seems to be no way out. He realizes that he is doing something wrong himself, but he wants to convince himself that he can consider his actions justified because he can help others with his lies.
Like a person who actively follows today’s phenomena, I also asked my question to artificial intelligence: Is lying sometimes allowed?
And this is how AI answered:
Lying can be seen as permissible in certain situations, but these situations can vary between cultures and individuals. Below are some examples of situations in which some may consider lying to be justified:
1. Protection: If lying helps protect another person’s physical or mental well-being. For example, you can lie if it helps protect the safety of your friend or family member.
2. Privacy: When it is necessary to protect your own privacy or the privacy of others, such as when you refuse to answer personal questions.
3. Surprises: If lying is related to planning surprises, such as keeping birthday gifts secret.
4. Play and art: Fictional writing, acting, and visual arts may be based on lies, but they are often seen as acceptable creative forms of expression.
However, it is important to note that while lying in these situations may be understandable, it does not mean that it is ethically unproblematic. Honesty and openness in general promote healthy relationships and strengthen trust. All in all, it is good to think carefully about when lying may be justified and when honesty would be a better option.
As theatre makers, we are free to create worlds and stories that don’t really exist. We create fiction, i.e. lies that we want the viewers to believe. We, the creators, must also believe in these lies – and lie with complete credibility.
In the theatre, lying is just a game, but in real life, lying can have fatal consequences.
Kari Arffman